IPR PTABCast: IN RE: Power Integrations

Author

Picture of Craige Thompson

Craige Thompson

Craige is an experienced engineer, accomplished patent attorney, and bestselling author.

Table of contents

Share

Gavel and question mark symbol on a desk, legal or patent law concept.
✎Executive Summary1 min read
Key Takeaways
  • In this PTABCast episode, Craige discusses a dispute over how to properly construe a single word in a patent claim: “couple.”
  • That one word had to be interpreted twice by the Patent Office, twice by the Federal Circuit, and once by a District Court, and its construction determined whether the patent was valid or invalid.
  • Adding one clarifying word to the claim at drafting time could have avoided millions of dollars in litigation expenses.
The Bottom Line: A single ambiguous claim term can single-handedly decide a patent’s validity, so precise, unambiguous claim drafting up front can save enormous litigation costs later.

Summary: Did the word “couple” really need to be interpreted twice by the PTO, twice by the Federal Circuit, and once by the District Court?

In today’s IPR PTABCast, Craige explains how the proper constructions of a single word can toggle a patent between validity and invalidity, and what you can do to avoid millions of dollars of litigation expenses by adding one clarifying word.

Questions? If you would like to get your patent questions answered and be part of the show, Thompson Patent Law has a LIVE complimentary webinar called Ask The Patent Attorney. Call the number below and reserve your spot in this LIVE teaching event.

Complimentary Patent Needs Assessment

related articles

Two construction engineers in safety vests and helmets reviewing blueprints at a building site.

IPR PTAB CAST

✎Executive Summary1 min read Key Takeaways This post introduces the IPR PTAB Cast, hosted by Craige Thompson

Legal scales and gavel symbolizing patent law and intellectual property rights.

Ipr Ptabcast: Nidec Motor Corporation V. Zhongshan Broad Ocean Co.

✎Executive Summary1 min read Key Takeaways This IPR PTABCast episode, titled ‘Patent Drafting Danger: Throw The Lists

Legal gavel and scales of justice on a wooden desk for patent law.

IPR PTABCast: In Re Smith International Inc.

✎Executive Summary1 min read Key Takeaways This PTABCast episode summary reports a win for patent owners: the